What's In vs Out For 2024


Happy...new year! Idk about you but I am feeling recharged and ready to hit the ground running tomorrow. I will keep this short because it's a holiday but wanted to hit you with a few thoughts as we prep for the new year.

You've probably seen a lot of "in vs out for 2024" and I thought I'd do one for the DTC industry as I see it. I'll leave a bit of context for some that are important. Let me know if you agree.

IN

  • Contribution Margin Dollars - As a marketer, it should be the main thing you obsess over
  • Incrementality - Stop caring what an ad platform says. Every dollar you spend should be held accountable. Does it drive real impact?
  • Creative Diversity - AI is here to stay. AI creative is pretty bad still, but the effect it will have on media buying is here to stay. You need to be producing drastically different types of creatives to reach different pockets of people.
  • Geo Lift Testing - Geo testing is the best way to measure incrementality.
  • Youtube Ads - Along the same lines. I think there is going to be a rise in DTC brands scaling Youtube Ads, profitably.
  • Performance Based Creative Agencies - Anyone who is worth their salt making ad creatives is going to charge on a % of spend model.
  • Upper Funnel Meta Ads - This year, I think a lot of brands will crack running video view or reach campaigns on Meta which will help them grow past what conversion ads can get them alone.

Out

  • Performance-Based Media Buying - On Meta at least, you simply won't be able to command the fees on media buying along. It's just too commoditized and you're not offering enough value unless you're doing creative as well.
  • Attribution - Caring about what an ad channel says it drove is so 2023. I'm not saying you shouldn't care about it, but wait yes I am.
  • TikTok - I am not bullish on TikTok. Shops is ruining the platform,and look at user growth . It's way down from the peak.
  • Cost Cap Arguments - Look, I like cost caps and bid caps. But I don't like dogmatism. You can succeed with many different strategies. Don't be dogmatic, and focus on what works in all scenarios, like a great product and great ads.
  • Variable Pricing For SAAS - You are going to see a push back against overly priced software this year, if you haven't already. Most tools are commoditized as well, so people are going to get pissed at the tools increasing prices or claiming a % of sales. If I wanted to make a decent biz, I would just "copy" one that did the same but charge a flat, capped fee instead of a variable fee.

Partner Of The Week - The one thing that is always going to be in is making really great, socially native ads. Mini Social is a great place to turn to when you need great ads. The easiest way to get micro-influencer content, at scale, in time for is Minisocial. They are the OG creator platform, and here is why I love them: First, you get paid content as well as organic distribution from vetted content creators and micro-influencers. Second, no long-term contracts, just pay per project. Their campaigns are fully managed by creator experts, no AI or software. Oh and you can get 25 videos for $1,700, which is a steal if you ask me. There's a reason they're trusted by top brands like Native, Olipop, and more. Start your campaign here to get ready for a massive 2024.

Tomorrow feels like the first day of school. It's exciting, but also a bit nerve-wracking. Hope everyone has a great 2024!

-Cody

  1. Listen to my Podcast with Eli Weiss called Down To Chat
  2. Get 1 On 1 Help On Mentorpass
  3. Try My Favorite Landing Page Replo

Some Additional Resources:


Unsubscribe ·

Cody Plofker

Hey, I’m Cody. I'm CMO of a 9 figure DTC brand and write a weekly newsletter with actionable marketing advice to make you a better marketer in 5 minutes a week.

Read more from Cody Plofker

Hey. Hope you're having a great week. We launched our holiday collection today; check it out and please buy one. One thing I'm trying to do is get much better at talking to customers. In the next year, I want to become customer-obsessed and creator-obsessed. I'm all about trying to simplify our business into the simplest frameworks possible. I tweeted about it here. I'm essentially trying to ask what are the big rocks we can focus on that it would be hard to fail if we did them well. Things...

Hey! It's late so I'm just gonna get right into it. I've been thinking a lot about how ad creative is evolving rapidly. If you're active on X, you've probably seen 100 posts about Andromeda and creative similarity. And for good reason. Things are changing and changing quick. Here are a bunch of things I currently believe about ad creative right now and going into 2026. By the way, I had an error in my last newsletter. If you want to get the $5k Roku Ads Manager credit, use code GET5K here....

Happy Thursday! Yesterday my team and I had lunch with our Applovin reps to do some Q4 planning and I wanted to share some of the tips they shared. We've recently been scaling up the channel with plans to really make a push in November so their ream was nice enough to come meet in person and help us plan. I wanted to share some of the tips I was able to that they shared with us. Hope this helps. And stay tuned till the end, because if you like this I have something for you. 1. Creative Is Key...